From dead ends to clear paths: How I redesigned a chatbot fallback for BMO Assist—Catherine Bryce Skip to main content
Catherine Bryce Knowledge systems · Information architecture · AI enablement

From dead ends to clear paths: How I redesigned a chatbot fallback for BMO Assist

Problem

Half of 1M+ chats ended in "I'm sorry, I didn't understand that."

My role

Content strategy lead, working with PM, design, engineering and QA.

The decision

Fix it with content now, not wait for model training: turn fallback into "fall-forward."

Result

Response success rate went from 45% to 86.5% in week one.

Before: the dead end

BMO Assist chatbot showing a generic fallback reply
When the bot wasn't confident, it apologized and stopped. Even near-matches got no help, so customers left or called.

The hard call: content first, not more training

The roadmap answer was to improve intent recognition through training. That was right long-term, but customers were failing today. I argued that success should mean the customer finishes the task, not the AI guessing correctly, and got PM to change the KPIs to match.

"What if fallback wasn't the end of the conversation, but helped them move forward?"

The system: options, not apologies

Short acknowledgement, then 2–4 clear options, then a safe way to reach a person. Over 300 options, written to three patterns: verb + noun ("Lock card"), noun ("Account balance"), question ("Why am I receiving alerts?").

Old experience flow: fallback response leads to contact us
Old flow: fallback sends people to "contact us."
New experience flow: full fall-forward response suggests relevant CTAs
New flow: fallback suggests the likeliest next steps.

Shipped

BMO Assist offering suggested options after a low-confidence match
Low-confidence match, with options.
BMO Assist fall-forward response with clear next steps
Clear next steps, no apology loop.
BMO Assist guiding a customer to update contact information
Guided task: update contact info.

Results, first week

86.5%
Response success rate, up from 45%
13,150
Fall-forward responses used
43%
Of all thumbs-up came from these responses

For many customers this was their first try at self-serve banking. Replacing the dead end made the channel feel worth coming back to.

Read the full write-up on UX Content Collective

← All projects Next: IVR lean UX workshop →